Monday, October 21, 2013

Abbado Conducts Mahler Symphonies 1-7 [Blu-ray]



Box Set Comparison to Individual Blu-Ray Releases
This review is for everyone wondering about the audio and video quality of this release in comparison to the original blu-ray releases.

NOTE: no comparison is made for Sym #7 as I only own the DVD of that symphony.

1) Video quality on all discs is identical to this release. Even though discs 1-3 now have double the content, they are on BD 50s and have the exact same bit rate
and have the same strengths and weaknesses. Symphony #3 looks the best with Sym #6 a close 2nd, again just like the original releases.

2) Audio quality: The Big Issue! First off, the back of the box makes it sound like there is no DTS-Master Audio track for disc 3. This is NOT the case. I don't know what that's all about, but I can confirm that the audio on Disc 3 (Symphonies 5 & 6) is identical to their respective original releases. There are two audio options for each disc LPCM 2.0 and DTS HD Master Audio 5.1.

Next, the controversial Symphony #2 (on Disc...

The Ultimate Mahler Cycle
As a dedicated classical music listener and audiophile for decades, I can say that this set has totally changed my view about the future of home entertainment. I was somewhat burned out on Mahler given the plethora of releases of his symphonies and numbers of live performances I have seen. I was also somewhat indifferent to Maestro Abbado, not having included much of his output previously in my collection. I knew him to be a great conductor, but there were plenty of other great ones, too, I thought.

All that changed dramatically upon obtaining this set. This is a definite "must have" among all other renditions of Mahler's symphonies. I doubt I will ever seek any other performances of these works after traversing this absolutely magnificent set. They are superbly and movingly performed by wonderful artists with superb sonics. But, the beautifully done video component adds a whole new dimension of insight into the passion, the sensitivity and the artistry of Mahler's...

Mahlers symphonies are complex.
Mahler along with Wagner, are two composers that you must done have some reading about their lives, as then you will obtain a better understanding of their music.I suggest 'Mahler, a life' by Jonathan Carr. It is not a weighty tome,but destroys some of the myths surrounding Mahler,and 'Mahler an Introduction to his music'by Deryck Cooke, obtained from Amazon.

Mahler's parents were ill suited, but it producted 14 children,of whom only seven survived. Much has been made about the fact that this had an effect upon Mahler. But the death rate when he was born in 1860 amongest infants were high.He grew up in Iglau,Moravia,near a military barracks, with its trumpet sounds, and bands, dance tunes in the town on Saturday nights and regional folk music. Nearby was the countryside, which became a refuge for him. Bernard Mahler, his father, noticed Gustav's musical talent, for he himself was attempting to better himself intellectually.He obtained a music teacher and eventually Gustav...

Click to Editorial Reviews

No comments:

Post a Comment