BLAZING
Having grown up on Callas' "Norma", I've never heard or witnessed any performer (including Sutherland, Caballe, Sills or Scotto) except Maria Callas in her prime that came close to fully encompassing the requirements of that role. Subsequent perfomers that I've seen or heard, merely gave rather lackluster readings just being glad to get through it in one piece. Therefore, I purchased this DVD of "Norma" with June Anderson thinking that I would simply have a well sung, rather bland performance of this "Mount Everest" of soprano roles. After all, an opportunity to witness and hear a "Norma" does not come along too often. Further more, (although she is not appreciated, too much, here in America) I've always enjoyed the singing of June Anderson since she made her first recording substituing for Caballe in the 1980s recording of Rossini's "Moses in Egypt" on the Philips' label. I also own and enjoy many of her recordings consisting mainly of operas (and/or arias) of Donizetti and Rossini...
Aims much nobler than results
This is an auspicious release in many ways. It could, and should, set THE standard for all and future NORMA performance practices, for it is more faithful to Bellini than practically any other rendering I have ever heard or seen. To begin with, it is more than complete, going beyond even the standard Ricordi score; Maurizio Biondi (brother of? uncle of? son of? father of? cousin of? - the conductor???) evidently consulted the autograph, and has made some important decisions regarding the textual factors - two of which I could readily discern (since Philip Gossett's name is listed on the credits, I wonder how much influence he had over the textual decisions; Gossett did an astonishingly thorough job in the Garland series of autograph facsimiles in sorting out all the endless variants, etc). The first, and which took me by complete shock, was the repeat of the *con dolore* melody in the prelude of Act Two. The first (and usually, the *only* one in standard performance practice)...
Yes she can!
The reviews of other writers are certainly mixed. Some say it's great some say it's awful. Well I'm a fan of June's and I say "Yes she can" and did. I think this is a most credible Norma. I can see the influence of scholar Phillip Gosset here in efforts at authenticity in fleshing out the usual cuts and errant practicies. ( I had the great fortune to audit his Opera History and Verdi courses at the University of Chicago.) I think the end effect is a fine Norma with good direction (Biondi), a really good bel canto Adelgisa (Barcellona), a rich-voiced Oroveso (Abdrazakov) and a misfit Pollione (Hoon). The tenor sang well and could do justice to the difficult bel canto line but he is no actor. He is stiff, unresponsive and small in stature. No match for a real man such as Jon Vickers was for Caballe or the best of them all Franco Corelli (he could make anybody's blood flow). And as for June, though not a natural actor she was not able to convey great emotional strife (better a little...
Click to Editorial Reviews
No comments:
Post a Comment